האלוף במיל' גרשון הכהן אומר שבמחשבה האסטרטגית המערבית, מתקיים קושי מתמשך בהבנת חשיבותו של ההקשר. השאיפה לכללים קבועים, לנוסחאות ולמתודולוגיה אחידה מובילה לעיתים לאובדן הרלוונטיות בשטח. זה נכון במיוחד בזרמים שמרניים, כמו הימין הפוליטי, שמעדיף להיצמד לעקרונות ולא מוכן להכיר בכך שהנסיבות משתנות תדיר.
אחת מנקודות הביקורת המרכזיות שמעלה הכהן נוגעת לגישה הדוגמטית כלפי אסטרטגיה. לדבריו, ההנחה שניתן להחיל עקרונות אחידים על כל מצב מתעלמת מכך שכל סיטואציה היא חד-פעמית, בעלת מרקם ייחודי משלה. גישה זו, לטענתו, מעקרת את יכולת החשיבה היצירתית והגמישה הדרושה להתמודדות עם מצבים מורכבים.
הכה מצביע על יתרון הגישה הלא-אשכנזית בעולם הרבני, שם לרבנים יש תפקיד קהילתי מובהק. הרב אינו רק פוסק הלכה אלא גם מנהיג שמזהה את ההקשר המקומי ומתאים את הדרכתו לצרכים הספציפיים של קהילתו. בכך, נוצרת גמישות שמרבים לפספס בגישות המתמטיות-פורמליסטיות של עולם ההלכה האשכנזי, כמו זו שזוהתה עם הרב סולובייצ'יק.
הגישה אותה מקדם הכהן קוראת להכרה בכך שהמציאות אינה ניתנת להכללה פשוטה. כל מצב דורש בחינה פרטנית של הנסיבות, והתעקשות על כללים אוניברסליים רק מסרסת את היכולת להבין ולהגיב נכונה. במילים אחרות, האסטרטגיה אינה מדע מדויק – היא אמנות הקשב להקשר המשתנה.
https://www.jns.org/idf-intercepts-rocket-fired-from-gaza-at-zikim-beach/
This is more a result of the Israeli government running the war against Gaza, as a public relations stunt, or act of diplomacy, than a serious war. The Israeli government does not bomb terrorists, or weapons locations when they become aware of them, because first they want to drop leaflets, so that the Jew haters of America might consider how compassionate they are.
Israels rules of engagement do not provoke fear among hamas, they induce confidence as to the foolishness and weakness of the Israeli government and nation.
We should take this threat seriously, we should come down on the Gazan population hard, we should force them to inform on hamas, and our posture is the complete opposite. The result of this will be many unfound weapons, and years of conflict, even if we manage to have Israels occupy the strip, and they will have plenty of missiles to paralyze the entire nation, whenever they find it politically expedient to do so. In G-d I trust.
Netanyahu would rather appease the Americans, then worry about delivering the IDF to guerrilla warfare for years to come.
מי מ״בני המקום״ רוצה ברית עם יהודים?
זה המוטו, ולשם מכוונת הפוליטיקה של ״מקומיים״
לכל היותר הם מוכנים לסטטוס קוו, מאפשרים את הקיום של ישראל כל עוד ישראל מעבירה למקומיים, אוד ועוד מתנות…
לא במקרה כ 50% ממוסמכי מקצועות הרפואה, הם ערבים
Meanwhile, on other occasions, the PA has supported the October 7th attacks, claiming it helped move towards ‘palestinian’ sovereignty. We have read media reports claiming that the pay to slay program is still in effect, even though our media has seemingly stopped reporting on it. Gigantic percentages of Muslims still appear to desire the conquest and subjugation of the Jews.
A situation that the French, and other Europeans cover up in their discourses, and narratives. In their news media, and their schools. What Jew wouldn’t be distrustful, of giving the made up people a nation, so that we can avoid talking about Arab Muslim racism against Jews, making peaceful coexistence with Jews impossible? What kind of farcical plan is that? You want us to indulge the lies of the nation of France, so that you can keep on lying, and covering up the massive security risk and harm that Jews have to live with? How is that a plan? While a billion Muslims scream about genocide and starvation of palestinians that does not exist?
Far more rational to take the Arab Muslims of Israel, at their word, when they would for decades, say that the palestinian nation is a tool, a step to bring about the destruction of Israel. The reason the Europeans and most of the American establishment wants Israel to stop defending itself, and imposing rational security requirements, fitting to hostile people, still dedicated to their racist supremacist goals, is because the Europeans and the Americans want to stop thinking and hearing about the Jews and the Muslims.
They want to go back to pretending that multiculturalism works. They don’t want to have arguments all the time, they want to not talk about Jew haters, and Muslim supremacists. They want to live in a world that they don’t hear about, where they pretend everyone is like them, everyone is a leftist, and everyone who isn’t is censored.
Well we Jews like to talk about the worlds problems. We like to talk about the worlds people. When we are forced to live under lies, it pains us, it angers us, and it provokes us to speak out. The people and leaders of America and Europe do not care about all their people who suffer for their censorship. They don’t care about those who perish or those whose lives are destroyed. They want to live selfish, foolish, frivolous lives, where they pretend that they made the right choice by dedicating themselves to wealth and power, not substance, character, and ideals. How can you live a selfish superficial life, when A gigantic problem exists in the world?
The majority of Americans and Europeans are indeed capable of believing stupid things. Like most people in this world, clear headedness, of what A person should be doing at any given time, to protect her nation, her people, her family, is something most women and men are oblivious to. They would rather talk about dumb things, talk about the weather, talk about gossip and sports.
If they do want to talk about immigration, they usually want to blame the Jews for it, rather than their own leaders for signing them up to be the worlds leading civilization. Being the worlds leading civilization would have responsibilities that come with it. They might have to set an example of how to manage race relations. Even among brave Americans and Europeans, a willingness to talk about illegal immigration, usually does not include non white inequality, nor does it include a talk about Muslim beliefs, behaviors and immigration.
They make little attempt to put two and two together, and wonder if Muslim hatred of non Muslims in the west and other parts of the world is the universal rule, why wouldn’t that be a problem for the Jews of Israel? How could the Jew of Israel possibly stop Muslim terrorism against them, when nobody else can stop Muslim terrorism? Nor stop Muslim violent crime against non Muslims?
Does Macron even make an argument, that Israel can allow disputed territory to be granted sovereignty, in highly intertwined borders with the Jewish nation? Is that safe for the Jews? While a majority of Muslims say, along with their leaders that they plan on continuing their war to conquer all of Israel, for made up palestine? Macron is a joke, and he was elected by the French people.
If the Jewish people submit to his kinds pressure, we will know nothing but failure, death and suffering. We are not seeing the problem, talking about the problem, measuring the problem, and implementing the best solution available for the problem. The way to manage Muslim Jew hatred, and the metestization of false narratives about land rights, is to end those lies. The ones that Muslims say, the ones that the French say, and the ones that the Americans say. In G-d I trust.
I could go on for much longer, but its also massively relevant to our case against a palestinian nation, to point out that in polls, Arab Muslims in Judea and Samaria don’t support the palestinian authority, they support hamas. Most concerning of all to the safety and clarity of the Jewish people of Israel, is the Israeli media and government not pointing out this massive intentional delusion the people of Europe and America live under.