הרשמה לניוזלטר

טופז רם: “צריך לומר לעולם שמעתה והלאה כל שטח שאנחנו משתלטים עליו הוא שלנו”

טופז רם מתריע: מדינה שלא יודעת להגדיר למה היא נלחמת, לא תוכל לגייס לגיטימציה פנימית או חיצונית להמשך קיומה

טופז רם, מציב מראה נוקבת מול פני החברה הישראלית. לדבריו, המשבר שישראל חווה אינו רק ביטחוני או פוליטי – אלא עמוק יותר: ערכי, מוסרי ותודעתי. מדינה שלא יודעת להגדיר למה היא נלחמת, לא תוכל לגייס לגיטימציה פנימית או חיצונית להמשך קיומה.

רם טוען כי בעשורים האחרונים ישראל נחלשה בעמידתה המוסרית דווקא בגלל נטישה של הזהות הלאומית והיהודית הבסיסית שלה. במקום להעמיד תפיסת עולם שלמה וברורה, היא מתמודדת עם גל של ביקורת בינלאומית, שיח אשמה פנימי והיעדר עמוד שדרה רעיוני. כשמדינה מגמגמת על עצם זכותה להיות – גם הצבא שלה יילחם מתוך מגננה ולא מתוך ביטחון בצדקת הדרך.

אחד הסמלים המובהקים לבלבול הזה, לדבריו, הוא אימוץ הביטוי “שטחים כבושים” כלפי אזורים שהם לב ההיסטוריה של העם היהודי. רם מדגיש כי מדובר במושג שמקורו בנרטיב פלסטיני ואנטי-ישראלי, שנועד לשלול את הקשר של ישראל ליהודה ושומרון, ולעצב את התודעה העולמית והפנימית כאילו מדובר בנוכחות בלתי חוקית. כאשר מדינת ישראל – או חלקים מתוכה – מאמצים את המונח הזה, הם מעניקים לגיטימציה לטענה המרכזית של אויביה: שישראל היא תוקפן, לא משחרר.

הבעיה אינה רק מושגית – אלא אסטרטגית. כאשר הדור הצעיר שומע בתקשורת, באקדמיה או בבתי המשפט שמדובר ב”כיבוש”, הוא מפנים מסר: אנחנו אשמים. כך נוצרת שחיקה עמוקה במוכנות להגן, באמונה בצדקת הדרך, ובתחושת החיבור למולדת. לטענת רם, לא ייתכן שישראל תילחם על שטח שהיא עצמה מגדירה כבעייתי מוסרית. בלי הכרה פנימית בחוקיות ובצדקת האחיזה במרחב, גם הטיעון הביטחוני מאבד תוקף.

הוא מזהיר כי הוויתור על ההגדרה העצמית מתחיל בשפה. ומדינה שמוותרת על הנרטיב שלה – תמצא את עצמה מוותרת גם על השטח עצמו.

רם מזהה סכנה מוחשית בכך שהציבור, ובמיוחד הדור הצעיר, מאבד את תחושת המשמעות – לא רק בנכונות להילחם, אלא גם באמון במדינה. מול מציאות שבה מערכות השלטון נאבקות זו בזו, והמסרים מתחלפים מיום ליום, קשה לבנות מחויבות לאומית יציבה.

ערוץ Tov אקטואליה יהודית ברשתות החברתיות

עוד באותו נושא
הצטרפו לניוזלטר וקבלו ספר חינם!
הרשמה
עדכן אותי
guest
2 תגובות
הישן ביותר
החדש ביותר המדורג ביותר
Inline Feedbacks
צפה בכל התגובות
Oren
Oren
22 ימים לפני

I wrote this in response to the recent tragedy in Gaza, immediately after Trump declared a cease fire with Iran. I agree that occupied territories, is a phrase and strategy that the Jewish nation should not embrace. We are a hated people, by most of the people of the world. We are ultra criticized, especially by the Arab Muslims. That hostility has influence over our national policies. Therefore, it is usually not possible for us to indulge vagaries, reasonable middle grounds, meant to make interactions less abrasive. Especially pertaining to the Arab Muslim adversary. This applies to the political realm as well as the realm of the individual, and the community.

I would point out that the financial realm of this world dominates the Israeli media, so we may need to build up a fortitude for defeatist terminology, if our advocates in the financial realms are not able to refute unfair wording, and the Israeli government is incapable of offsetting the attacks on the minds of the Jews of Israel suffer.

Additionally, what Topaz Ram says is true, that an Israel that does not understand what it is, who others like the Arab Muslims, the Americans and white Europeans are, is a nation that is very likely to mismanage the aggression it faces. Under reacting to it, and misunderstanding the opposition that it is certain to receive from the west. An Israel unprepared for disengagement with America, the military equipment that it provides, as well as the political cover.

But I think Mr. Ram is making a mistake. Our narrative moves slowly, as do our peoples thoughts. We must first refute multiculturalism, before we attain the permission for our own right to exist, and be different, in our own minds, and that of our society.

Multiculturalism is the refutation of the significance of all peoples, of all skin colors, of the lasting effects of inequality, of religions and ideas. Our people are open to claims of our immorality, and deeply effected by them.

Multiculturalism embraces censorship and lies, false accusations, threats and utilization of demonization. Many of its adherents are un-impregnable with ideas that contradict their world view. Because if you embrace the idea that you can censor ideas you don’t like, or walk away from conversations you don’t want to have, you can force people dealing with you to only use force, be it political or physical, to deal with you. You have built a fortress of justifications, defending you from emotions that you don’t want to have, exempting you from upsetting truths and conversations.

We must defeat the multicultural philosophy, as well as learn to accept that the Jewish people, in the Jewish nation are alone in being able to attain that level of perception, and policies that defend our people and nation from a world filled with hatred over inequality. America and Europe survive by cutting themselves off from the world and reality. That is how they have so far maintained their multicultural beliefs.

There are other impediments to changing the minds of multiculturalists. If popular opinion is all that you care about, or the feelings of popularity, consensus, positive reinforcement, are what your heart and mind desire, then that is a very high bar to persuade you. You will have to wait for us to conquer the TV, in order to be saved.

 Additionally, there is considerable evidence that the human mind is not based on logic in vast numbers and percentages. That human emotion is an extension of a level of morality, a worldview, induced by the choices that we make, and the ideas that we embrace. We think the world is a certain way, or a certain aspect of it is a certain way, and then we treat the world according to how we think it is. How we can best deduce to manipulate it for our benefit. This adds to the immovability of peoples thoughts and personalities. Heavily contradicting the thought of conquering through kindness and love.

These strategies of the multicult, work in the lives of women, as best as they are able to make happy marriages, homes and families. It is not surprising that a world of ideas and emotions so foreign to them, like war, the deception that is justified, to better harm the enemy, and defend the people, is massively different than the female way of thinking. Causing them to make bad judgment calls often over those issues of conflicting peoples like Jews and gentiles. Due to Jewish religious narratives, I believe that we will eventually reach the conclusion that female thinking is not ‘fit for purpose’, for leading management and resolution of conflicts between peoples.

What we need to make progress against that disfunction in our societies thinking, is to identify the problem to the men, as well as the women who can understand it and accept it. Work on getting agreement to view women as different, less capable in the realm of competition and war. Then releasing statistics about the opinions of men, as well as the opinions of military men, pertaining to a matter.

Israeli military leadership may or may not be undermined by the hostile desires of the world, represented through the financial realm of the world. So, the general soldiers opinions should be considered as a strong testimony as to what is logical. We should worry about the power of the hatred of the world, that Israeli generals are aware of, but as of right now they seem to be overwhelmed by foreign influences, making it impossible for us to tell Israeli generals apart. Those who give honest testimony, and those who misrepresent the situation in order to better serve their benefactors.

 Israeli leadership does not reflect the importance of morality and G-d in this world, or the Jewish people to lead the fight against ideas destructive to civilization. They seem to reflect the current acceptable narratives in the media, and probably on the streets. Ideas that are destructive, that we are trying to overcome. For now the cry of the world is simplistic, we want Jews to stop fighting against Muslims! It is clearly perceivable in the desires of American presidents.

 We will probably have to get used to a foolish and racist call of the world telling the Jews not to fight back against those who desire to hurt us. We will have to get used to the idea that America including Trump, will indulge those ideas, and pretend they are reasonable. I have reached conclusions in other articles I wrote, that it would appear that the right description of who the American nation is, even under Trump, is a nation that is dominated by the left, promotes the left, and only does the right moral thing begrudgingly. Stealing the credit for the good deed it was forced to do. B”H

Oren
Oren
22 ימים לפני
הגב ל  Oren

A tragedy. A lifetime of tears dished out to all of their families.

It is sad that just being a Jew, means that we have to live with constant reminder of how much we are hated, how unreasonable and irrational our adversaries are, and how much danger our people are always in. We thank these Jews, and their families, for making the ultimate sacrifice, so that we can go to sleep safely at night. So that we can laugh over funny jokes with friends, and complain about our economic troubles.

We live on, knowing that until we improve our living situation, or solve it, we will still be indebted to the Jews who unfortunately run into one of the many monsters who hate the Jewish people, either on our streets, or on our borders, and in between. May G-d grant our souls the love and blessing we need, to overcome the emotional hangups, and philosophical mistakes, that hold back our people, from stopping this terrible and endless price.

We live in a world where a vast number of people, walk around, believing alternative realities, where people of their skin color are right, and people with other skin colors, or religions, are wrong. That is how a large percentage of the population views the world. The world media, overwhelmingly protects them from reality, because they don’t have a way to manage interactions with people who are fundamentally abusive to others, but completely dependent on them for their economic well being. They hate the unequal, but they follow the unequal, wherever they go.

 They are living evidence of the fundamental flaw of the multicultural hope and feeling. Nations like America are to invested in multiculturalism to change, so are the Europeans. They are willing to disregard all of their democratic commitments, all of their narratives about human rights and equality, just to avoid confronting the evidence before their eyes. That their way of life, is not sustainable. They will bend their media and their courts, their entire political processes, just to support the idea that multiculturalism makes sense, and that it can work out. Millions of people continue to flood into America and Europe, based on the idea that people of every people, skin color, and religion, can live together in peace and harmony, regardless of achievement levels.

We acknowledge the leftist call for us Jews to stop hurting others, to stop discriminating against them, to stop insulting them and their people, with our words. We honor the leftist sentiment, we empathize with it, and we consider it, to the best of our ability to do so. But we have gigantic quantities of evidence that point to an alternative conclusion as to the best way to navigate a world of unequal people and nations. We have thousands of years, of middle eastern history in our Jewish religious books, that tell numerous repeated stories, of vast cities, and entire nations, screaming in hatred, calling for death to the Jews. We can see evidence of the failures of toleration to conquer the hearts of men in America and Europe as well.

Our history and those calls of hatred contradict the idea that no middle eastern people are capable of racism. The tremendous amount of evidence, contradicts the claim that all we need to do to solve the problems of Jewish peaceful coexistence with the people of the world, starting with the people of the middle east, is to treat them with perfect equality, and total acceptance and love. That is not enough to end all wars, stop all hatred, and make inequality, and the hatred that emanates from it, end. Once and for all.

I sometimes wonder if every casualty the Jewish people suffer is an act of G-d. Correlating exactly to how the nation feels. A recent victory over Iran, induces anxiety that the Jew can be a winner, over popular opinion, leveraging moral superiority and unequal military capabilities, in defiance of the western claim that every person should have a vote to determine what policies should be embraced.

Even for nations like Iran who act like additional evidence that hatred of Jews, provokes mindless, repetitive and endless dedication to war, aggression, death and killing. A nation whose leadership supports seemingly suicidal objectives, attaining nuclear weapons, and threatening to use them before even having them. Using terrorists to target civilians, when their military is incapable of winning the battle honorably. Firing missiles at Israel, in the hopes of randomly hitting a Jew, and causing us suffering, when their entire nations air space is completely dominated by Israel, and their entire population could be wiped out, if the Jewish people were the mass murderers that they claim we are.

Can we Jews be comfortable with victory? Can we even picture it? Our nation and leadership, on the world stage, defeating the forces of evil, when in so many ways, in our lives we are forced to submit to violent monsters all around us, in America and in Israel? When we are so accustomed, to lowering our heads, abiding our time, in the hopes of one day getting ourselves free from the dangerous situation that we have been forced to live with?

Due to a to large a percentage of our population that is dedicated to the idea that we can make all the people of the world tolerant of differences among peoples, make the men and women of the world the types of people that celebrate inequality, and are happy for the benefit that they receive thanks to the exceptional achievements of other human beings?

A belief that sin can be eradicated or sufficiently reduced to enable our safety and happiness, by simple kindness and acceptance. Including the Jew hatred of the entire world. I pray that the sacrifice of these wonderful young Jews, fighting for our nation, will cause our people to consider the endless hatred that we live under. A victory over Muslim Jew hatred, causes zero introspection among the obviously Jew hating Muslims of Gaza or Israel. First we admit that multiculturalism does not work for the Jewish people, in the Jewish nation, and then we can start to ask what does work. In G-d I trust.

כתבות נוספות

עייפים כל הזמן? מתעוררים בלילה? 6 סיבות נפוצות ואיך מתמודדים איתן

כולנו חווים תקופות שבהן השינה לא רציפה, הקימה בבוקר קשה במיוחד, והעייפות נמשכת לאורך כל היום. לפעמים אנחנו מאשימים את הלחץ, ולעיתים פשוט את גילנו או מזג האוויר – אבל בפועל יש כמה סיבות מפתיעות (ומשפיעות) לעייפות כרונית והפרעות שינה. החדשות הטובות: יש גם דרכים להתמודד

לחיות עם חתול: על תזונה, היגיינה ומה שביניהם 

 גידול חתול מביא עמו שמחה גדולה והרבה חום לבית. הם יצורים עצמאיים ומרתקים, ובתמורה לקשר הייחודי שהם מציעים, מוטלת עלינו האחריות לדאוג לבריאותם ואיכות חייהם. דאגה זו מתחילה בהבנת הצרכים הבסיפיים שלהם: תזונה נכונה, סביבת מחיה נקייה ותשומת לב לפרטים הקטנים

הצטרפו לניוזלטר קבלו ספר חינם!

תחזית מזג האוויר

אפשר לבחור ערים מסוימות בלחיצה על המיקום

זמני היום

2
0
מה אתם חושבים? נשמח שתגיבו.x